"The Ban Lawsuits" - News and Legal Analysis

All the posts about pediatric gender medicine by the author of Bad Facts

Last updated Dec. 6, 2024

This is an index of all the essays and X threads by Glenna Goldis about legal challenges to pediatric gender medicine (PGM) in the US.

General Background

• Chase Strangio’s Legal Narrative

  • The trickery at the heart of the ACLU’s legal strategy

• Can Science Take Down Gender Doctors?

  • The role of evidence-based medicine in litigation

• The Vanishing Legal Case for Pediatric Gender Medicine (6/30/24)

• David v. Goliath and the ACLU

  • The giant corporate law firms that partner with trans rights advocates in most of these lawsuits

• Idaho Comes for the American Academy of Pediatrics

  • States are investigating the AAP over its pro-PGM “Policy Statement”

• The “Transgender Child” Is Born

  • How Americans got the idea to socially transition their young children

• The Trans Teen Illusion (Part 1, Part 2)

  • Adults have been failing “trans” teens since the 1960s

Alabama

• Lawyers for “Trans Kids” Face Sanctions in Alabama (March 2024)

• ACLU Cover Up in Alabama? (June 2024)

Arkansas

The Trial (published as “The Brandt Files”)

• Introduction

• #1: Don’t Say Gay at the LGBTQ Rights Trial

  • Gayness

  • Gender nonconformity

• #2: On “Gender Identity”

• #3: Before the First Shot

  • Dan Karasic (psychiatrist)

  • WPATH guidelines

  • ROGD

• #4: Side Effects? Haven’t Seen ‘Em

  • Deanna Adkins (endocrinologist)

  • Side effects, risks, and complications

• #5: Mom and Dad Ace Obedience School

  • The pressures that parents face

  • Suicide myth

• #6: A Race-Baiter Takes the Stand

  • Jack Turban (psychiatrist)

  • Expert witness law

• #7: Our Heroes Scale the Hierarchy of Oppression

  • Equal protection law

  • Defining trans

• #8: Why not make a logical argument?

  • Gender dysphoria

  • Disability law

  • Past trans litigation

• #9: The ACLU’s Deal with the Doctors

  • Past trans litigation

  • ACLU lawyers

• #10: How Judge James M. Moody, Jr., Disposed of Arkansas

  • Stephen Levine (psychiatrist)

  • Religion

  • Media coverage

• #11: What They Didn’t Argue

  • Paul Hruz (endocrinologist)

  • Passing

  • The mythical biological basis of gender identity
    

The Appeal

• Arkansas Doesn’t Contest the “Facts”

  • Oral argument at the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals

  • We’re now waiting for the decision

Florida

• “Unrestrained Puberty”: Notes on the Florida Loss

• The ban is back in effect — for now. The 11th Circuit Court of Appeals stayed the trial court’s ruling. We’re now waiting for oral argument in that court.

Missouri

In Nov. 2024, a state court upheld Missouri’s ban after trial. It’s headed to appeals now. (No writing on this decision.)

Ohio

The good guys' first trial win (X thread)

Tennessee

This one’s before the US Supreme Court. It’s called US v. Skrmetti. A decision is expected in June 2025, possibly earlier.

• Who’s Who in US v. Skrmetti

• Biden administration’s brief (X thread)

• Historians’ amicus brief (X thread)

• Healthcare lobbyists’ amicus brief (X thread)

• Even more amicus briefs (X thread)